Ded na si Lolo (2009) Reviews

• Definitely not the best of Philippine Cinema for 2009

  myc49712009-11-02

  Cmon out of all the releases this year, I refuse to believe that this is the most fitting movie to represent Philippine Cinema in one of the most prestigious award giving body in the world. Seriously? It's a joke. Although I would agree that the premise of the movie was a great idea although not entirely original. But it stops there, everything else FAILED... miserably. The acting was average at best. The screenplay was crap, I could have totally watched the movie in fast forward and tell the story in 15 minutes. Direction was all over. There was not even one redeeming factor in the movie that I could think of. And saying that this is the best movie to represent Philippine Cinema... unforgivable failure. OK fine, I get it that some conservative members of the academy wants a movie that will feature the traditions and the local culture but to make it the ONLY criteria, you should have sent a travelogue or a TVC of the Department of Tourism.

• A Very Filipino Film

  3xHCCH2009-11-13

  The movie is about how a family of five adult siblings coped with the death and the wake of their father, as simple as that. But within that bare context, Mr. Topacio was able inject very familiar Filipino situations that make us laugh out loud, and tug some heartstrings in the process. A central theme element is the depiction of various irrational superstitions that surround death, the wake and the funeral. It also tackles uniquely Filipino practices during the wake, including the gambling operations (saklaan). The inter-family conflicts among the siblings are also very well-limned and very realistic. As it is sharp, the words of the script were really very witty. It is very obvious that the movie also succeeds because of the excellent cast. Mr. Topacio himself acknowledged that the secret of this movie's success is that he was able to get the actors he wanted. The siblings were played by veteran actors Dick Israel, Elizabeth Oropesa, Gina Alajar, Roderick Paulate, and Manilyn Reynes. Paulate, as expected with his flamboyant role as the gay son Junie, steals all his scenes, even when he does not have dialog. They play their comically-overmelodramatic roles with gusto and fun. Their interactions are quite carefree and natural, in both funny and dramatic situations. I am glad I watched this movie. I think it would be a good movie for competition abroad because of its perfect rendering of the Filipino ways, very masang Pinoy indeed. I really wanted to see how the humorous Filipino dialog would come out in English, how much nuance could be lost. I am also concerned that a narrow-minded foreign audience might treat the whole movie as an inside joke that they do not get. I was hoping they would show the subtitled version today, but they didn't. Last year's Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film went to a movie about death customs as well, "Departures" from Japan. But certainly, as the quietness of that movie made it uniquely Japanese, the noise and festivity of "Ded Na Si Lolo" makes it uniquely Pinoy. I believe it deserves its shot at the big prize.